It's nothing huge, don't worry... but don't you hate how you agonize over the small things, when you can make major decisions in a couple of blinks? (Or maybe you don't. You probably think the big stuff over for a reasonable amount of time, and then make a well-thought-out decision. This is why I'm coming to you for help.)
The sitch is this: I play the piano for Relief Society. From the very first day I stepped in I've been asking to get the weekly hymns in advance so that I can practice them (so as not to suck). (Sorry for saying 'suck' in a church-y post.) No one seems to plan the hymns in advance (there is a music coordinator, but I haven't seen her at RS for months. I think she's been having some health/mobility issues). Here's the problem: the sitch is making me crazy.
I TOLD you it was nothing huge.
I love the hymns. They are actually a lot harder to play than you might expect, and they're even harder to play when you're trying to follow a conductor while a bunch of people are singing along to what you're playing (or in my case, trying frantically to play). No one will let me know in advance what hymns to look at (at least, not without -me- pulling -their- teeth), they just say 'Oh, you pick - anything you like' two minutes before the meeting starts. So here's my dilemma: How do I tell the teachers and/or RS Presidency that I am not 'down with this' without sounding preachy, petty, whiny, and/or self-righteous? (Point one: It may not be possible, as I could very well be one of all of these things. Unfortunately. Point two: My RS Pres is pretty blog-saavy, and may check in here before I actually decide what to do. She's cool, though, and may have some good suggestions. Hi, Naomi! You rock!)I want to help build the kingdom, and I don't want to criticize. I want to be positive and helpful, not all growly and finger-pointy. I also want to define some acceptable limits so that I don't chew down my back teeth. (This is a very dental-adjacent post, for some reason.) So, at the moment I'm thinking of a letter, something like this:
"Dear wonderful RS teachers:
Thank you so much for your love and work on the lessons! I think you might be missing an opportunity, though, and I'd like to share it with you. The hymns we sing in Relief Society are a chance to both set the mood for your lesson and wrap it up/support it on the way out. I, the pianist, have a very limited repetoire of hymns that I can play well, and I depend on getting a little notice in order to practice them so that I can help your lessons.
Here's the opportunity: I'm playing as a volunteer, not because it's a calling - I haven't been blessed or set apart to have any particular insight into what you'll be teaching. I'm also a student looking at an extremely busy second term. However, I am very willing to do what I can to practice whatever hymns will best speak for your lessons - otherwise, I'm afraid I'm going to have to give you a list of the songs I actually can play (I think there's about 10) and we'll have to choose from those the day of if there isn't something picked out at least a couple of days ahead of time. You've all been very kind about mentioning how well I play - trust me, I cringe over every wrong note. If I can't practice, I can't improve, and I just don't have time this term to learn ALL the hymns! I want to help, I really do, and a hymn that 1) supports your lesson and 2) helps the sisters learn and become familiar with a wide range of hymns (also known as 'Scripture') can only be a good thing.
I know our Music Coordinator has been dealing with other things and hasn't been around, so I'll make this request one more time. Could you please get me two hymns that you'd like sung with your lesson by the Wednesday before you teach? (Or, do like Amy Hunt did the week before last and give me the song numbers the week before in church! It was awesome.) I will make every effort to practice. I may not be perfect, but I'll feel a lot better about the effort - and that much less stress means I'll be able to enjoy your lessons even more. I do hope you don't mind my asking! If this is too much pressure for you, I understand and I'll get you that list of hymns.
Thank you, ladies -
Charisse"
* * * * *
So, what do you think? Am I really as obnoxious as I'm starting to suspect I am? There's something of a tendency over here to expect other people in the Church to 'take care of' things (and with some validity: I am playing, after all) and I don't want to enable that any more. IT'S SUCH A SMALL STUPID THING, I KNOW, and I am almost as frustrated by the fact that I'm frustrated about it as I am frustrated about the initial... frustration. Sheesh. Do I send (well, Facebook Message) this letter (or some version of it)? Do I shut up and start meditation exercises, and learn two news hymns a week? Do I draw hymn numbers out of a hat and play those, regardless of the lesson topic? (I... actually really like that last one. Hmmm.)
Please help me not go postal on my sweet Relief Society sisters and the generally pretty cool Relief Society presidency. Help me to sharetheloooooove and maketheworldabetterplaaaaaace, instead.
Especially not over 'hymn choice.' Over pornography, smoking in the bathroom*, or the ward Christmas party, sure. Not the hymns.
Thanks. I'll be in the corner, chewing on my fingernails in order to give my molars a break.
Weigh in!**
* Not that anyone I know has ever done this. Particularly not at church. Or during a Ward Council meeting. Allegedly.
** That means 'please comment' and GUIDE MEEEEEEE.
6 comments:
Your letter sounds directly appropriate and full of love and understanding of their calling. I would send it. It will likely mean more work for you, but you could also find out who is teaching the week before and reach out to them. I don't think you should have to do that so if it comes to that it would be post "here are the songs I can play" list.
love/miss you
Can you check and see if the RS lessons are tied to sacrament talks at all? More often than not, here at home, RS lessons go right along with whatever theme is done in sacrament meeting. If they are, that could help you be in touch with bishopric and know in advance.
Do they hold ward council/PEC? Maybe if your music director is not attending those, you could volunteer to go in her place? You could be the one coordinating music with the lessons?
I think your friend has a great idea - if worst comes to worst, have a list that you have practiced and have in your back pocket just ready to go - whether they fit with the theme or not?
I have never learned to play the piano, but I know how hard it has been watching Ceana learn to play for YW and other things. Hymns ARE hard and you are awesome to keep giving it such effort and devotion to set the tone and invite the spirit.
Keep at it. Pray and listen, keep talking to the right people, you are doing everything you can. It will all work out great!
Keep us posted on how things come about -k- We will keep updated here too.
Hugs!
I love your letter and think it's great to provide a "Songs I can Play" list. Two other things that might help--do you have a copy of Hymns Made Easy or the Simplified Hymns? Hymns Made Easy has 60 hymns and is even online on lds.org. Simplified Hymns has almost all of the hymns. I have copies of both and if you'll send me your address I'll be happy to send them to you!
Noted. I'll sort this. I like the title blog savvy. xxx
First, the letter sounds fine. Second, you could always just stick with your ten songs and they'll eventually get tired of singing "Sweet Hour of Prayer" every other week. And my final note--after years of being an accompanist (though not in this ward and don't get me started!)--really don't worry about "following" the conductor. Just play. Half the conductor's don't have a clue what they're doing anyway. Cheers!
Maybe the letter is fine for RS. From a guy perspective though, it's WAY too many words. I'd suggest just letting the leadership (whoever is conducting) know that you would like to coordinate the music with the lesson, but without notice by Wednesday then everyone will get one of the ten. If they give you a suggestion during the week then you just increased the "pool" by one! Maybe if nobody makes a suggestion, you just go ahead and pick a new one to add to "the list"?
I suspect most or all the lessons might be pre-planned by someone, even if you don't know who that is yet. I know all the lessons for Sunday School (adult and youth), Priesthood and Relief Society for the rest of the year except a few conference-talk-based ones during the second half of 2012. It could be there's a list somewhere, and that you just need to go see the Wizard.
$0.02
Post a Comment